Should you build a dual occupancy or a granny flat?

When designing a home for investment, there are two popular options that people have in mind: a dual occupancy home and a granny flat. Naturally, our clients ask themselves and us, “Should I build a dual occupancy home or a granny flat?” While we usually attempt to answer as straightforwardly as possible, like our responses …

14 September, 2021
Should you build a dual occupancy or a granny flat?

When designing a home for investment, there are two popular options that people have in mind: a dual occupancy home and a granny flat. Naturally, our clients ask themselves and us, “Should I build a dual occupancy home or a granny flat?” While we usually attempt to answer as straightforwardly as possible, like our responses to most things in our business, our answer is usually, “It depends on you.”

You may think that by responding with that we are taking the easy way out, however, it’s as honest an answer that we can give. Dual occupancy homes and granny flats are both excellent options for abodes, however, they have different strengths and weaknesses, those of which are dependent on a person’s lifestyle, needs and future goals. Without knowing what these are and without understanding their financial and time limitations, it’s hard for our team to provide a definitive answer.

How does our team guide clients to the best option?

Our approach is personal. We want to get to know you, your family and your life. Then, we guide you through each property type, go through their key features and main differences and generally talk you through your options. We’ll never go to our initial consultations with one set solution in mind. Our design solutions are meant to be tailor to you so that you can get the most out of your property.
A dual occupancy home can be either attached or detached. An attached dual occupancy home has two dwellings that are attached to each other (through a common wall) and located on one lot of land. A detached dual occupancy home is two separate dwellings that exist on one lot of land.
A granny flat is slightly different from a dual occupancy home (though very similar). It is a self-contained dwelling that is part of the main building and under the same title. It can be attached or detached and is often on the same lot. It is frequently designed as a smaller version of the main house. A granny flat is considered a secondary dwelling, unlike dual occupancy homes.
Let’s now take a look at some of the factors our team will assess when determining whether a dual occupancy home or a granny flat is right for you.

Dual occupancy property

Here are a few key points to note with a dual occupancy property:

  • It can be subdivided into separate properties
  • Utilities and leases can be separated if renting
  • You can construct a separate entrance
  • Both dwellings will be full and complete homes

You must ensure that a dual occupancy home can be built in the specific local council zoning area. Dual occupancy homes must comply with specific planning controls which include a minimum site area and a minimum site width which are specified by your local council.

Who is a dual occupancy right for?

Dual occupancy homes are very versatile. They are perfect for families interested in an additional income stream through renting or selling as it is very easy to separate utility bills.

Though dual occupancy homes may be more costly than granny flats to construct, they have an impressive return on investment because it is considered “a complete home” and has a separate entrance. Renters are more likely to opt for another dwelling in a dual occupancy home because it is more separate and private than a granny flat. This allows you to invest in your future quicker and pay off any pending construction costs easily.

Granny flat

Here are a few key points to consider with a granny flat:

  • They fall under the same title as the main house
  • It is built in conjunction with the main dwelling
  • Usually patterned after the main house’s design
  • Subdivision is not permitted with a granny flat (opposite of a dual occupancy)

Only the primary (main house) and secondary dwelling (granny flat) are allowed on a lot of land. As it cannot be subdivided, it is not suited to homeowners who will eventually want to sell it for a profit in the future (though it can be sold with the primary dwelling). Utilities also cannot be separated, making renting more difficult.


Who is a granny flat right for?

Granny flats are right for people who may want to keep their elderly parents close. It can also be beneficial to provide adolescent children with a place to stay while they sort out their own homes. It is a great option for renting to short-term tenants, however, if that is your main goal, we recommend a dual occupancy home.

For more property and design advice, contact the ES Design team.

Your Source of Building design News and Information

Stay up to date with the latest industry news, including key changes to planning and design regulation. 

3 July, 2024
Local and state government performance to be tracked in bid to deliver housing targets

With the recent amendment to the State Environmental Planning Policy (Housing) 2021, NSW Government is committed to reaching the National Housing Accord target of 377,000 homes by mid-2029. In order to achieve this, the Minns Government is holding local and state governments accountable through a range of performance measures. The Housing SEPP amendment has brought …

1 July, 2024
Amendment to Housing SEPP to encourage low- and mid-rise housing in ‘well located areas’

In alignment with the National Housing Accord and following on from the proposal for low- and mid-rise reforms that went on exhibition from 15 December 2023 to 23 February 2024, NSW Government has introduced new amendments to the State Environmental Planning Policy (Housing) 2021. The aim of these reforms is to increase supply of low-rise …

15 December, 2023
Introducing the Mid Rise Housing Diversity Code

Today, the Department of Planning and Environment placed on exhibition a document to help accelerate housing delivery in NSW. This document suggests some changes to the low rise housing diversity code that impacts dual occupancies, manor houses and terraces but also brings in multi dwelling housing, residential flat buildings and shop top housing; all of …


Load more articles